
I’m not a scientist. I’m just a Joe Schmoe, philosophizing from my lumpy armchair. Still, I’m hopelessly curious about current thinking regarding the nature of consciousness and reality.
A lot of talk these days about how we might be “living in a simulation.” Alluded to, even, by people I see as credible.
Neil deGrasse Tyson recently said something to the effect that (he believes) there’s a 50/50 chance we’re living in a simulation.
I (vaguely) get what’s being said.
Given our current technology and its mind-bogglingly rapid evolution, what if another civilization had an extra ten thousand or million years? In that time, surely, they could create simulations so real they’d be indistinguishable from reality.
Okay. Yeah. Maybe. Heck, probably.
So, the proposition goes something like this:
We (eight billion-plus Earthlings) have no biological, material existence. We are, rather, no more than machinery imagining consciousness and all the apparent lives that proceed from that. All very real from our perspective but, in fact, not real at all. Unplug it, and it all goes away.
Big Question One
Simply, WHY?
If you’re this super-advanced civilization, what’s the fascination with observing (if that’s what they’re doing) inferior beings and their mostly dull lives? Surely, these beings are infinitely more intelligent.
Of all the things this theoretical culture might do with its astonishing tech, why the hell are they bothering with simulated human experiences? Does it even make sense?
What are they hoping to learn from cavemen like us?
Big Question Two
Isn’t this “we’re living in a simulation” notion sort of the opposite of Occam’s Razor? Is this idea really “the simplest explanation” of any damn thing at all?
Big Question Three
If we’re going to make this wildly insane (to me) proposition, why stop there?
Maybe this imagined superior civilization is merely in someone else’s simulation.
Honestly, why not? Why not an infinite regression of simulations?
I mean, as long as we’re tossing out Occam and his Razor.
……………………………
That’s all I got.
Observations?